| Baseball | 2013 | 15 of 20 * | Columbus Pounders | JBL-3 | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 26% | Chris's Cool Bracket | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 133 of 152 | Chris's Cool Bracket | Bdangles Buckeyes | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 230 of 500 | SayWhat!!? | Cali NCAA Tourney Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 30% | 123PICK | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 50% | SayWhat!!? | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 313 of 500 | 123PICK | ohio lakes and rivers | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 130 of 500 | Chris' Crazy Bracket | BSPT Win Prizes Contest | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 71% | Chris' Crazy Bracket | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Women's Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 45% | SayWhat!!? | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Women's Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 39 of 61 | SayWhat!!? | CFSA Women's NCAA Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2012 | 9 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL-3 | No | Yes |
| Basketball | 2012 | 3 of 16 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2012 | 90% | BuckEyEs | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2012 | 106 of 186 | BucksIn2013 | Beat Mike College Bowl 2012 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2012 | 73% | BucksIn2013 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2012 | 39 of 274 | BuckEyEs | CFSA College Bowl Pick'em | No | Yes |
| College Football Pick'em | 2012 | 7 of 16 | Buckeyes2013 | BMN College Ball Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Football | 2012 | 14 of 20 | Columbus Dawgpound | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2012 | 35 of 75 | DaBrowns | BMN Season XIV | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2012 | 4 of 21 | Dawgpound | CFSA Salary Cap Football | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2012 | 72% | Dawgpound | Overall | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 60% | TheNut2012 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 110 of 500 | TheNut2012 | Ohio State Fans | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 229 of 500 | DaBucks | ohio lakes and rivers | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 39% | DaBucks | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 227 of 500 | CanIGetAN.O.H.I.O | Cali NCAA Tourney Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 52% | CanIGetAN.O.H.I.O | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 43% | Bucks12 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 8 of 10 | CSBucks | Dynotec | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 42% | CSBucks | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 47% | Bucks12 | Drew Brees - Dream Big | No | No |
| Women's Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 34 of 44 | Buckeyes2012 | CFSA Women's NCAA Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Women's Tournament Pick'em | 2012 | 25% | Buckeyes2012 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Baseball | 2011 | 11 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL-3 | No | Yes |
| Basketball | 2011 | 8 of 16 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2011 | 118 of 500 | BucksNextYear | Beat Mike College Bowl 2011 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2011 | 91% | BucksNextYear | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Football Pick'em | 2011 | 8 of 16 | BrutusTime | BMN College Ball Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Football | 2011 | 2 of 20 | Columbus Dawgpound | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2011 | 44 of 74 | HillisTheBeast | BMN Season XIII | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2011 | 2 of 3 | Dawgpound | CFSA Salary Cap League | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2011 | 77% | Dawgpound | Overall | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 78% | OH-Buckeyes-IO | Fans of Ohio St. | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 74% | OH-Buckeyes-IO | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 17% | Bucks123 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 456 of 500 | Bucks123 | Bracket challenge | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 3 of 9 | O$UallTHEway | JNCAA | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 48% | O$UallTHEway | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 66% | BuckeyeNut | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 77% | OSURemixed | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 174 of 500 | BuckeyeNut | Cali NCAA Tourney Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 39% | JustBecause | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 13 of 19 | Chris Saul | DYNOTEC INC | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 53% | Chris Saul | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 288 of 500 | JustBecause | MyPartyShirt.com March Madness | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | 159 of 500 | OSURemixed | ohio lakes and rivers | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2010 | 5 of 12 | OH-Slammers | Yahoo Public 163807 | No | No |
| Baseball | 2010 | 6 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL-3 | No | Yes |
| Basketball | 2010 | 17 of 20 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2010 | 368 of 500 | PoisonousNut2010 | Beat Mike College Bowl 2010 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2010 | 28% | PoisonousNut2010 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Football Pick'em | 2010 | 9 of 24 | OSUBucks4Real | BMN College Ball Pick'em | No | Yes |
| Football | 2010 | 7 of 20 | Columbus Dawgpound | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2010 | 4 of 49 | Browns2ndChance | BMN Season XII | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 17% | Sweet16Buckeyes | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 2 of 11 | OSU#1 | Buckeye Nation | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 78% | OSU#1 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 33 of 43 | Sweet16Buckeyes | BMN College Basketball 2010 | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 44% | ETMVP | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 7 of 11 | ETMVP | Buckeye Nation | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 77% | 1moreyearEvan | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 51 of 376 | Buckeyes2010 | Fans of Ohio State | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 17 of 87 | 1moreyearEvan | Evan Turner is #1 | No | Yes |
| Second Chance Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 82% | Buckeyes2010 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Survival Football | 2010 | dead | DawgpoundIsBack | BMN Survivor League | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 158 of 500 | BuckeyePower | MID-OHIO NCAA 10' | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 93% | O-H-I-O | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 83 of 500 | O-H-I-O | BigTenProud!!! | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 65% | BuckeyePower | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 44% | TurnerMVP | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 34% | OSU2010 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 7 of 7 | OSU2010 | JL College Basketball 2010 | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 17% | What??? | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 38 of 48 | What??? | BMN College Basketball 2010 | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 279 of 500 | TurnerMVP | Fans of Ohio State | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2009 | 8 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL3 | No | Yes |
| Basketball | 2009 | 19 of 20 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2009 | 1 of 21 | OH-IO | Beat Mike College Bowl 2009 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2009 | 94% | OH-IO | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2009 | 3 of 8 | Buckeyes | JL College Bowl Pick'em 2009 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2009 | 78% | Buckeyes | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Football Pick'em | 2009 | 7 of 19 | OH_all the way_IO | JL CFB Challenge | No | Yes |
| Football | 2009 | 7 of 20 | Columbus Dawgpound | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Golf | 2009 | 6198 of 12486 | TeeTime | Fans of Tiger Woods | No | Yes |
| Golf | 2009 | 46% | TeeTime | Overall | No | No |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2009 | 8 of 22 | BrownsIn2010 | BMN Season XI | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2009 | 12 of 27 | SuperBrowns | JL NFL Challenge | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2009 | 4 of 16 | Hardcore Browns | Grubby Salary Cap | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2009 | 73% | Hardcore Browns | Overall | No | No |
| Survival Football | 2009 | dead | GoBrowns | Can you survive? | Yes | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2009 | 6 of 40 | GOBUCKEYES | JL NCAA Tourney Challenge VI | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2009 | 83% | GOBUCKEYES | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Baseball | 2008 | 10 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL3 | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2008 | 1 of 12 | Tribe Smashers | Yahoo Public 258258 | No | No |
| Basketball | 2008 | 9 of 20 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2008 | 17 of 19 | OSUBigTenChamps | BMN College Bowl Pick'em | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2008 | 20 of 23 | The Ohio State University | JL College Bowl Challenge | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2008 | 22% | The Ohio State University | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2008 | 32% | OSUBigTenChamps | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Football Pick'em | 2008 | 9 of 19 | Buckeyes#1 | JL CFB Challenge | No | Yes |
| College Football Pick'em | 2008 | 3 of 14 | Buckeyes#1 | BMN College Football | No | Yes |
| Football | 2008 | 13 of 20 | Columbus Dawgpound | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Football | 2008 | 4 of 10 | Columbus Slashers | Smashmouth Football League | Yes | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2008 | 9 of 27 | Browns4Real | JL NFL Challenge | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2008 | 10 of 18 | Browns4Real | BMN SEASON 10 | No | Yes |
| Survival Football | 2008 | 1 of 6 | BrownsSuperBowl? | Can you survive? | Yes | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2008 | 22 of 38 | The Final Battle | JL NCAA Tourney Challenge V | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2008 | 49% | The Final Battle | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2008 | 57% | Buckeyes#1in2009 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2008 | 5 of 10 | Buckeyes#1in2009 | BMN College B-Ball Challenge | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2007 | 9 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL3 | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2007 | 3 of 10 | Columbus Sluggers | The Power Club | Yes | Yes |
| Basketball | 2007 | 15 of 20 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2007 | 26 of 27 | Bucks#1 | JL College Bowl Challenge | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2007 | 14% | Bucks#1 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Football Pick'em | 2007 | 1 of 13 | BeanieWells | Beat Mike CFB | No | Yes |
| College Football Pick'em | 2007 | 5 of 18 | BuckeyesAllTheWay | JL CFB Challenge | No | Yes |
| Football | 2007 | 3 of 10 | Browns Champs 2010 | Sunday Showdown | Yes | Yes |
| Football | 2007 | 13 of 20 | Dawgpound Soldiers | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2007 | 12 of 28 | BrownsFutureChamps | JL NFL Challenge | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2007 | 7 of 19 | ABC123 | Beat Mike Season 9 | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2007 | 65% | Big Money | Overall | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 52% | GoBuckeyes | Fans of Ohio St. | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 63% | GoBuckeyes | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 67% | Bucks#1 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 6 of 13 | Bucks#1 | BMN March Madness 2007 | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 9 of 34 | BucksFinal4 | JL NCAA Tourney Challenge IV | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 73% | BucksFinal4 | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Baseball | 2006 | 5 of 10 | #1Tribe | World Baseball Classic | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2006 | 6 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL3 | No | Yes |
| Basketball | 2006 | 16 of 20 | Cavs Attack | JRL1 | No | Yes |
| College Football Pick'em | 2006 | 3 of 20 | GoBucks | JL CFB Challenge | No | Yes |
| Football | 2006 | 2 of 10 | Hardcore Browns | Steven Jackson likes to play | No | Yes |
| Football | 2006 | 17 of 20 | Dawgpound Soldiers | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Football | 2006 | 1 of 10 | Dawgpound06 | Football 101 | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2006 | 22 of 39 | Red White & Boom | Beat Mike-The 8th Season | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2006 | 8 of 31 | Dawgpound #1 | JL NFL Challenge | No | Yes |
| Salary Cap Football | 2006 | 73% | Dawgpound Stars | Overall | No | No |
| Salary Cap Football | 2006 | 8 of 27 | Dawgpound Stars | Salary Attack | Yes | Yes |
| Survival Football | 2006 | winner | Pick123 | JohnWhorfin's League | No | Yes |
| Survival Football | 2006 | dead | GoBrowns! | CanYouSurvive2? | Yes | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2006 | 18% | BuckeyeGlory | Overall | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2006 | 38 of 49 | BuckeyeGlory | JL NCAA Tourney Challenge | No | Yes |
| Baseball | 2005 | 13 of 20 | Columbus Pounders | JBL3 | No | Yes |
| Football | 2005 | 17 of 20 | Dawgpound Stars | JFL3 | No | Yes |
| Pro Football Pick'em | 2005 | 12 of 37 | Dawgpound | Beat Mike Network League | No | Yes |
| Survival Football | 2005 | alive | GoBrowns | CanYouSurvive? | Yes | Yes |