
| Game | Year | Rank | Team | League | Commissioner | Private League |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tournament Pick'em | 2013 | 20% | GO Friars | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2012 | 72% | peerformation | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2012 | 5 of 10 | peerformation | Nathan's College Bowl Pool | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | N/A | bruins | Nathan's NCAA Tourney Group | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2011 | N/A | bruins | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | N/A | tnicf | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2010 | 4 of 33 | tnicf | ScoutFriars | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2009 | N/A | LesMilesmustgo | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2009 | 1 of 3 | LesMilesmustgo | Fantasy Bowling League | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2009 | N/A | TNICF | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2009 | 24 of 33 | TNICF | OutsideProvidence | Yes | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2009 | N/A | tnicf | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2008 | 1 of 2 | RussellShepardshallleadus | Fanz of Football | No | Yes |
| College Bowl Pick'em | 2008 | N/A | RussellShepardshallleadus | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2008 | N/A | Poor facilities | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2008 | 11 of 61 | Poor facilities | 2nd Annual FI Tourney | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | 46 of 50 | Welshmustgo | Keeping Our Minds off the NIT | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2007 | N/A | Welshmustgo | Overall Leaders | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2004 | 10% | ouryear | Overall | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2004 | 48 of 48 | ouryear | Projoboard | Yes | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2003 | 22% | cajunfriar | Overall | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2002 | 2 of 11 | cajunfriar | Exis Hoops | No | Yes |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2002 | 81% | cajunfriar | Overall | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2001 | 27% | cajunfriar | Overall | No | No |
| Tournament Pick'em | 2000 | N/A | NextyearFriars | Fans of Butler | No | No |